top of page

100 Mistakes Home Sellers Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Updated: Dec 8, 2022

Are you looking to sell your Toronto home? Here’s our best advice for avoiding the 100 most common mistakes Sellers make.

1. Being home for showings.

The National Association of REALTORS claims this is the number one reason homes stay on the market for a long time. If a showing is scheduled, leave the house.

2. Thinking you will get a 100% return on your renovations.

Sadly, this is only true on TV. Always talk to your REALTOR before you make any renovations for the sale.

Related: How renovations affect the value of your home.

3. Restricting showing times to be convenient for you.

Opening your home to potential Buyers is a pain, but it’s to your advantage to make it as convenient for them as possible. We recommend allowing showings between 10 am and 8 pm, 7 days a week.

4. Picking your REALTOR because they are your friend.

If they’re the best person for the job and you can fire them if they don’t perform, go for it.

Related: Should You Hire Your Friend To Sell Your House?.

5. Thinking just having your home on the MLS will sell it.

There’s a lot more to marketing your home than just putting it on the MLS, at least if you want to sell it for top dollar. Hire an agent who knows how to expose your home beyond the MLS and don’t ever accept mediocre marketing.

Related: How We Reach More Buyers

6. Not insisting on stunning professional photography.

Most Buyers first see the home they eventually buy online, so outstanding photography is critical. If a Buyer bypasses your listing because of bad photos, they aren’t likely to reconsider it later.

7. Not deep-cleaning your house before putting it on the market.

Buyers assume that homes that are messy or dirty haven’t been properly maintained either…which means less interest from Buyers and lower offers. Don’t feel like cleaning? Bring in a professional (or work with an agent who’ll take care of this for you, like the BREL team).

8. Not tidying up before EVERY showing.

Make your bed, wash the dishes, put away your laundry, clean the floors — every time.

9. Leaving your dog in the house for a showing.

I know it’s hard to believe, but not everybody loves dogs. Don’t detract from a showing by having a barking pup.

Related: Selling a Home With Pets.

10. Over-pricing your home and expecting buyers will negotiate.

Most Toronto Buyers will avoid an overpriced house rather than negotiate, so if your pricing strategy is to over-price by $50K and negotiate down to market value, recognize that you’ll be overlooked by most Buyers and may not get the chance to negotiate. If your listing lingers on the market, you might end up selling for less than market value.

Related: You can read more about pricing strategies here.

Related: The Lowdown on Pricing a House

Related: The Lowdown on Pricing Condo

11. Walking away from an offer because you’re insulted it’s too low.

While not everybody wants to negotiate, some Buyers are expecting to. So while you may get an offer that’s $50K below market value, the Buyers may very well be prepared to increase their offer substantially. Avoid getting emotional at offer time and look to your agent for guidance on negotiation strategies.

12. Not knowing what to repair and renovate before selling.

It’s just as bad to over-repair and over-renovate as it is to ignore the important things that will matter to Buyers.

Related: What Repairs Should I Make Before Putting My House on the Market?

13. Not understanding the importance of staging.

To bring in the highest possible price, it’s important to showcase your home at it’s absolute best, and that likely means you’ll need to stage it. Optimize the use of every room for the typical Buyer (instead of how you live). Professional staging can quite literally add tens of thousands of dollars to your sale price.

Related: Read more about BREL’s very own staging company here – and it’s included in our commission.

14. Not using colour and accessories to make the photos pop.

One of the biggest goals of staging your home before listing it for sale is to make your home look amazing in photos – and pops of colour and the right accessories can make a huge difference.

15. Thinking your house is the best on the block.

Truth: over 80% of Buyers think their home is better than average and that’s only true 50% of the time. When planning your selling and pricing strategy, be honest with yourself. If you aren’t sure how you compare to your neighbours, ask your agent. If you’re still not sure, consider visiting some open houses in the area or ask your agent to take you to see your competition.

16. Not fixing the small things.

Buyers often exaggerate how much it will cost to fix the small things, so take the time to fix the leaky faucet, re-caulk the bathtub and repair the hole in the wall – it’ll cost you far less than the discount a Buyer will apply.

17. Buying before selling or selling before buying.

There’s no easy answer as to whether you should buy or sell first, so take everything into consideration and talk to your REALTOR.

Related: Read more about Deciding Whether to Buy or Sell First here.

18. Not recognizing the seasonality of real estate.

Real estate is seasonal, and there are ideal months (and less ideal months) to sell, and it’s not always what you’d think. For example? In Toronto, the ‘spring market’ tends to start in February. Talk to your agent.

19. Not tracking the competition and adjusting accordingly.

Buyers won’t just be looking at your home; they’ll be scouring everything that’s for sale. Track new listings that might appeal to the same Buyer as your home track what is and is not selling before you. Track which listings are taking offers on what days so you don’t schedule your ‘bidding war date’ on the same night as your main competitor.

20. Thinking you have all the answers.

There’s a lot more that goes into selling a home than you probably realize. Great REALTORS have listed hundreds of homes for sale and that expertise results in higher prices and faster sales.

21. Thinking your opinion doesn’t matter.

True, you should be able to depend on the expertise of your REALTOR to guide you through the selling and negotiating process, but remember: all the big decisions are yours. You decide on the asking price and the selling price. You decide when the timing is right to list your home and how much you should invest in home preparation.

22. Not reading what you sign.

You’ll be asked to sign a lot of paperwork – make sure you read and understand it all.

23. Not proofing your listing before it goes on the MLS.

The details matter and you’ll be held legally liable for what’s written on your MLS listing, so double-check that it is 100% accurate before it goes public. Check the lot size, the square footage, the description of the features and materials, the size and makeup of the rooms, what’s included in the condo fees, how much the property taxes are, etc. Read every word and ask questions if you don’t understand something. Yes, this IS your agent’s job…but better to be safe than sorry.

24. Forgetting to focus on curb appeal.

Buyers will often eliminate a house based on how it looks from the outside, so make a plan to maximize the curb appeal of your home.

Related: Click here for tips on Maximizing Curb Appeal.

25. Not searching for your own home on

It can take a couple of days before your home shows up on, the number one website used by Toronto Buyers. Yes, your REALTOR should be checking to make sure it looks good online, but it never hurts to look at it from the Buyers perspective. Is the first photo the best photo? Does the description sound appealing? Is it showing up in the right neighbourhood?

26. Not insisting your home gets properly marketed online.

Remember: the goal is to get as many Buyers as possible to see your home, and that means marketing it online, where people are already spending their time. Hire an agent with a powerful website and an engaged social media following. (shameless plug: more Buyers see BREL listings on our website than on

27. Not realizing that the Buyer is entitled to receive the home in the same condition it was in when they bought it.

Your responsibilities as a homeowner don’t end when you sign the agreement of purchase and sale…you must deliver the home on the closing day, in the same condition it was in when the Buyer offered to buy it. If the furnace or appliances break down before the closing day or the basement floods, you’ll need to fix it.

28. Not disclosing what you need to disclose.

Sellers (and their agents) must disclose anything that might impact a Buyer’s enjoyment of a home. While it might be tempting to hide the knob and tube wiring or the problem with the foundation, it’ll cost you greatly in a lawsuit.

Related: Read more about what you need to disclose to potential Buyers here.

29. Leaving garbage/unwanted furniture behind when you move.

Most agreements of purchase and sale include a clause requiring that the home is left in a broom-swept condition on closing. Under no circumstances should you leave garbage or old furniture in the home for the new Buyer to deal with.

30. Not understanding your options during an offer negotiation.

Whether you get a bully offer, bidding war or just a plain old offer, it’s important to understand the process and your options.

Related: What to Expect on Offer Night

Related: What to Expect If You Get a Bidding War

Related: What to Expect If You Get a Bully Offer

31. Not realizing the impact of the weather on your sale.

Buyers stay home during snow storms and ice storms, so watch the forecast and plan accordingly. If you don’t have air conditioning, don’t list your home for sale during a heat wave.

32. Not doing due diligence on the agent you hire.

Sadly, there are a lot of false and deceptive claims made by some REALTORS. Question their statistics, ask what their awards mean and make sure you understand any of the ‘guarantees’ they might be providing.

Related: Find out more about Deceptive REALTOR Claims and Stats here.

33. Not taking out half your things out of your closets before listing.

Buyers see closets jammed full of off-season clothes, shoes and luggage and they almost always conclude there isn’t enough storage in your home. Take out half of your things and send them to storage during the sale.

34. Not interviewing multiple agents before choosing one.

Read reviews. Ask your friends and family. Do your homework.

Related: Here’s a list of questions to ask.

35. Hiring a REALTOR for the wrong reasons.

Who you choose to sell your home will impact how much money you walk away with and the experience you have during the selling process. Don’t make the mistake of just hiring the agent who offers the lowest commission or who promises the highest price. Ask questions and hire for experience and expertise.

Related: Read more about the wrong reasons to hire a listing agent here.

36. Lying to your agent about what’s wrong with your house.

Your REALTOR is on your side, so be honest with them. They’ll be able to guide you about what you need to disclose and can help Buyers overcome the objections. It’s your agent’s job to protect you, and since you can’t hide from your house, it’s better to have a strategy to deal with the not-so-great things about your house.

37. Not attending the condo meetings and not being on top of issues with the condo board.

If your condo is planning a special assessment, repairs or renovations or involved in a lawsuit, you need to know. You’ll need to account for those issues in your timing, pricing and selling strategies.

38. Ignoring maintenance for years and then expecting top dollar when you sell.

If you haven’t been taking care of your home, you’ll suffer the consequences of that neglect in how much money you sell your home for. That doesn’t mean your home won’t sell – but you’ll need to be realistic about price. Don’t expect to sell it for the same price as your neighbour’s immaculately maintained home.

39. Not recognizing the impact of a smelly house.

Clean the litter boxes, avoid cooking smelly food and empty the diaper pail and garbage can before every showing. Be careful when using room sprays and atomizers – they might do more harm than good.

49. Smoking in your home.

Never EVER smoke in your home. Studies show it can devalue a home by up to 14%.

41. Testing the market with no real intention to sell.

Are you really motivated to sell? While ‘testing the market’ might be a fun game to play, it’s important to recognize that your agent is likely spending thousands of dollars and a lot of time trying to get your home sold. If your intention is merely to test the market, be honest with your agent.

42. Thinking you can kick your tenants out while they are in a lease.

In Ontario, selling your home isn’t a valid reason to evict the tenants while there’s a valid lease in place…but if they’re month-to-month tenants, you can give 60-days notice (from the 1st of the month)

Related: Click here to read more about Selling a Tenanted Property.

43. Leaving out drugs/drug paraphernalia/sex toys/weird collections for showings.

Don’t distract the Buyer from falling in love with your home. Put away anything that might offend a Buyer.

44. Listing/selling before you have your ducks in a row.

Once you’ve agreed to sell your home to a Buyer, there’s no backing out, so make sure you’ve considered everything from costs to timing to deposits and what you can afford in your next move.

Related: Are You Ready to Sell?

45. Closing on the same day you close on your new home.

Not everything goes according to plan on the closing day. If you can close on your new home a few days before you close on the home you’re selling, you’ll have some buffer for unexpected delays, Bonus: it makes moving a lot easier.

46. Not inquiring about bridge financing before you agree to closing dates.

Bridge financing is temporary financing that helps you bridge the gap between the time you take possession of your new home and when you close on your existing home. It essentially allows you to fund the downpayment for the new property with the equity in your current home. Make sure to talk to your lender to ensure that you qualify before you agree to any closing dates.

Related: What’s the Deal With Bridge Financing?

47. Expecting to renegotiate a firm sale.

Once you’ve reached an agreement with the Buyer and they’ve waived all conditions, the sale is firm, and you won’t likely be able to re-open negotiations. The Buyer has no obligation to agree to a new closing date, and you can’t just change your mind what is and is not included in the sale.

48. Accepting a bully offer in a hot market.

If you’ve priced your home for multiple offers and have scheduled an ‘offer night’, be careful about accepting pre-emptive offers. In our experience, you’ll almost always get more money if you wait until offer night.

Related: You can read more about the pros and cons of bully offers here.

49. Thinking nobody will buy your house.

Every house sells if it’s staged, marketed and priced appropriately.

50. Not listening to the market’s feedback about your home and adjusting accordingly.

Buyers give feedback in many ways: they might tell their REALTOR what they think of your home (“this home smells like cat pee”); they might send a message by not scheduling showings (“this home is overpriced for the location”), or they might see it and not make an offer (which could mean a lot of things). When the market speaks, you need to listen. You might need to stage your home differently or have new photos taken or adjust the asking price. Your REALTOR can guide you.

51. Not critically evaluating why your home isn’t selling.

If your home has been on the market for longer than it usually takes to sell in your neighbourhood, something is wrong. Check out our blog, This is Why Your Home’s Not Selling for a checklist of what might be happening.

52. Not allowing your agent to host an open house.